Broadly, jacobson charts an initial period in the early republic of relative racial inclusion that was based on. The color of whiteness and the paradox of diversity. Race, whiteness, and the imitation of life see imitation of life john stahl, 1934 before classmake sure to see the 1934. Whiteness of a different color is a subtle and sensitive exegesis and deconstruction of the immigrant experience in american culture. In this sense it is a living creature changing shape and color, looking different depending on how we view it. Jacobson m f 1998 whiteness of a different colour european immigration and the from sociology 1 at lane college.
Though the particulars changed, americans continually color coded their visions of the one and the many. Matthew frye jacobson delves into this notion of people not fitting into groups and then how those groups changed in his book whiteness of a different color. Located at the intersection of law and representation, the color of whiteness demonstrates that the racial ideology of whiteness is not fundamentally reducible to color. Noncitizen nationals and american empire beas, arguing that as a native inhabitant of puerto rico. Whiteness of a different color ebook by matthew frye jacobson. Sep 03, 2009 racial and ethnic politics in the united states. Americas racial odyssey is the subject of this remarkable work of.
European immigrants and the alchemy of race by matthew frye jacobson 19990901. Oct 22, 2012 matthew frye jacobson delves into this notion of people not fitting into groups and then how those groups changed in his book whiteness of a different color. John white, times higher education supplement jacobson builds a history of how the category of whiteness plays in american history. Whiteness of a different color matthew frye jacobson harvard.
Jacobson documents cultural shifts from 1790 until the 1960s in which a multiracial system of white races, defined in opposition to the. Whiteness of a different color electronic resource. European immigrants and the alchemy of race by matthew frye jacobson 19980930. Screening of the jazz singer alan crosland, 1927 discussion of jazz singer and jacobson reading quiz. Whiteness of a different color demonstrates the ways in which the meaning of whiteness has been historically contested in the united states, and is organized according to three great epochs of whiteness. In doing so he argues that whiteness is not just socially constructed, but that its also much more fluid, overlapping, and historically contingent than we might think. Other brief discussions include cabranes, supra note 1, at 56 n. It is a theory of who is who, of who belongs and who. Though the particulars changed, americans continually colorcoded their visions of the one and the many. Discussion on the book whiteness of a different color, by matthew frye jacobson. A classical reader 1996 werner sollors, beyond ethnicity 1986 ronald takaki, a different mirror 1993. Yet another valuable work in the field by a sociologist is the ethnic myth. A pdf copy of this bibliography also will be available for.
Some of it is dated but it has some really great passages on the blurred lines between color i. His book is in many ways a continuation of the work that barbara fields and others have done. European immigrants and the alchemy of race by matthew frye jacobson. In this chapter, i seek to deconstruct the underlying structure of the notion of diversity as it is commonly used in the united states. The second great transformation in the rural north, 18701930. To view the full text please use the links above to select your preferred format. Fall 2001 jacobson, matthew, whiteness of a different color. Working toward whiteness left a greater mark on me than any of the other books that i read during that period though. Possessive investment in whiteness by george lipsitz. European immigrants and the alchemy of race matthew frye jacobson work cite jacobson, matthew fyre. European immigrants and the alchemy of race sorry document has been removed or not existed. His goal is to demystify, and the tone he takes does exactly that.
Two recent books examine color coding in american history. Meehan page 2 reading list, us immigrationethnic identity, minor field. In whiteness of a different color, matthew jacobson draws upon congressional legislation and discourse, historical documents and memoirs, and popular culture in an attempt to explain racisms affect on immigration, american domestic and foreign policy, and the selfperceptions of various racial and ethnic groups in the united states. His analysis of the european immigrant experience, american racial classifications and their fluidity over time is a valuable addition to the flourishing genre of whiteness studies in the fields of labour and workingclass history, represented by such books as theodore allens invention of the. John white times higher education supplement jacobson builds a history of how the category of whiteness plays in american historyhis goal is to demystify, and the tone he takes does exactly that. George lipsitz, the possessive investment in whiteness. Whiteness of a different color european immigrants. Stanford libraries official online search tool for books, media, journals, databases, government documents and more. Racial categories have been fluid over time to suit political and socioeconomic needs. European immigrants and the alchemy of race, i was again reminded that race may be imagined but that did not mean it was not a very real part of peoples lives. In everchanging racial categories we glimpse the competing theories of history and. Analysis on the book the wages of whiteness, by david r. So some of the current notions of who a different people was overdetermined by this kind of attention. Matthew frye jacobson is a professor of american studies at yale.
Matthew frye jacobson argues that race resides not in nature but in the contingencies of politics and culture. Douglas hartmann, university of minnesota joseph gerteis, university of minnesota paul r. Jacobson m f 1998 whiteness of a different colour european. As matthew frye jacobson notes, racism is fundamentally a theory of history.
Ge whiteness of a different color european immigrants and the alchemy of race matthew frye jacobson harvard university press cambridge. Jacob thus recognizes on some level that, in the u. European immigrants and the alchemy of race cambridge, mass. Read whiteness of a different color by matthew frye jacobson available from rakuten kobo. Citations to archival documents will be rendered in boxfiledocument format. The negro problem, the mormon problem, and the pursuit. The second great transformation in the rural north, 18701930 chapel hill. Colormanaged documents in adobe acrobat provide greater control over the appearance of the final document.
How americas immigrants became white by david roediger. He particularly focuses on the ambiguity and shifting. Race, ethnicity and class in america by stephen steinberg, which documents how ethnicracial boundaries. European immigrants and the alchemy of race by matthew frye jacobson 19990901 on. Matthew frye jacobson, whiteness of a different color 1998 maxine hong kingston, the woman warrior 1976 nella larsen, quicksand and passing 1928, 1929 jerre mangione, mount allegro 1942 werner sollors, ed. We have seen some positive changes in our country since cswacs founding in 1995, but much remains distressingly the same, or in the backlash of. View jacobson1 from ethn 100 at university of san diego. Whiteness of a different color details how race is a mostly political construct and, as in my example above, varies not on biology primarily but on politics. Students will be expected to read the equivalent of one scholarly monograph a week, facilitate discussion once during the semester, attend humanities institute lectures, produce a 1520 page. Andrew gyorys closing the gate and matthew jacobson s whiteness of a different color explore the realm lying between black and white through the lens of immigration history. Whiteness of a different color robert speaks with matthew frye jacobson, author of the new book whiteness of a different color. Whiteness, rather, is a category of racialized power that canand mustbe historicized, resisted, and undone.
European immigrants and the alchemy of race in searchworks catalog. European immigrants and the alchemy of race, matthew frye jacobson examines how the variegated white races merged in the public consciousness into caucasians from. White like me and color blind by tim wise worked to the bone by pem davidson buck. Capturing the excitement of the new field of whiteness studies and linking it to traditional historical inquiry, jacobson shows that in this nation of immigrants race has been at the core of civic assimilation. Whiteness of a different color oxford academic journals.
Jesus and the strongman in america, 18931920 rachel lindsey notes my sincere thanks to leigh eric schmidt, annie blazer, and kate moran for their substantive feedback on early drafts of this article, to princeton universitys american religious history colloquium for reading the very first. In general, comparison with the united states limits the consideration of race in latin america or, in this case, argentina and. The fabrication of race and the political history of whiteness, from whiteness of a different color by matthew frye jacobson. Vicissitudes of whiteness in american politics and culture matthew frye jacobson we perceive race as a feature of the natural landscape, fixed in the unchanging realities of biology, but racial categories change markedly in response to shifting political, economic, and social circumstances across historical time. Jan 28, 20 reading matthew frye jacobsons whiteness of a different color. Whiteness of a different color by matthew frye jacobson. Whiteness of a different color ebook by matthew frye. Matthew frye jacobson, whiteness of a different color. Prejudice and ethnocentrism arise when whiteness is the standard from which other ethnic and racial categories diverge and deviate. In this work of historical imagination, jacobson argues that race resides in contingencies of politics and culture. These web sites compromise the educational process.
Ge whiteness of a different color european immigrants and the alchemy of race matthew. Racialized social democracy and the white problem in american studies american quarterly 47. He is the author of whiteness of a different color. Andrew gyorys closing the gate and matthew jacobsons whiteness of a different color explore the realm lying between black and white through the lens of immigration history. Today a variety of terms are used to refer to white identity including whiteness, white studies, internalized white superiority, and white supremacy. Jesus and the strongman in america, 18931920 rachel lindsey notes. While ive had to stop and think about other sources that i was working off of as i go through and backfill books ive read into goodreads, this book never left the forefront of my mind. Smith is right, and in this article i expand on his analysis. Decentering whiteness 2015 edition decentering whiteness. Matthew frye jacobson argues that race resides not in nature but.
I take the title of the conclusion of my book from whiteness of a different color. Whiteness of a different color by matthew frye jacobson the. Reading matthew frye jacobsons whiteness of a different color. A brief history with documents nativismwhiteness arnesen. European immigrants and the alchemy of race matthew frye jacobson. American studies 301 john ibson on monday, april 29, you must submit an ethnography that examines a place with which you were not already familiar at. Croll, augustana college this paper employs data from a recent national survey to offer an empirical assessment of core theoretical tenets of whiteness studies.
Ill also post important documents such as this syllabus on the class titanium site. Towards a bibliography of critical whiteness studies. Whiteness of a different color matthew frye jacobson. Reading matthew frye jacobson s whiteness of a different color. Jacobson, matthew frye, whiteness of a different color. Two recent books examine colorcoding in american history. To deconstruct history as a chameleon we will look at disparate accounts of events, conduct interviews to test the value of memory and orality, analyze readings about controversies to assess the variations of.
982 1088 1465 633 96 153 493 852 1275 636 450 1137 1563 1510 401 1221 1201 917 859 1630 541 616 132 1598 124 1002 883 1154 416 306 769 100 584 477 367 1224 211 634 215 1138